Why We Get Angry at Injustice If All Truth Is Just an Opinion.
We love the phrase: “That’s your truth.” It feels open. It feels flexible. It’s the ultimate modern safety net.
Everyone gets their own truth. It’s the new golden rule.
But let’s be honest. It’s a lie we abandon the second we see real injustice.
Imagine scrolling through your feed. You see that devastating story. The woman killed on the train. The senseless violence. The outrage immediately splits into two furious camps.
One camp demands accountability: Why was this dangerous man released from prison? They are angry at the objective failure of the justice system.
The other camp demands empathy: They argue the system failed the murderer, too. They say his history justifies his actions. They believe the only truth is that the criminal is the true victim.
Here’s the impossible problem for the modern world: By what standard are you angry?
If objective truth is truly dead—if the universe is just a random accident—then your outrage is meaningless noise. It’s a chemical reaction in your brain. It has no more universal authority than when you laugh.
If all morals are subjective, then the murderer’s action is just their truth. The outrage on both sides is just two equal, competing feelings.
You cannot logically demand an objective, universal punishment, or a universal demand for empathy for something you claim isn’t an objective, universal truth.
It’s a paradox that leaves everyone exhausted and polarized.
Academic experts even agree. The rise of polarization isn’t just about politics; it’s about “moral outrage.” Scholars found this intense combination of anger and disgust is what’s driving people to dehumanize their opponents online and commit to sophistry (just making bad arguments). The whole system is breaking down because we’re shouting about a moral code we can’t locate.
The Echo of the Law.
So, why do you get so fiercely, gut-wrenchingly angry at injustice? Why does that line feel so real?
Because, deep down, you know the line is real. It’s not imaginary.
Your outrage is not a random chemical spike. It’s an echo. It is the sound of a fixed, unchanging law bouncing off the walls of your subjective world.
The Bible explains why this echo is so loud. It explains why you instinctively know right from wrong, even if you’ve never picked up a Bible.
They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness, and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them. — Romans 2:15 (ESV)
The feeling of injustice—the fury that says, “This should not be!”—is not your invention. It’s proof that the work of the law is written on your heart.
You have a moral standard built in. It’s part of being human.
The Truth Is Not in the Way. The Truth is the Way.
The problem isn’t that truth is in the way of your life. The problem is that you are desperately trying to live according to an objective moral law without acknowledging its objective Lawgiver.
The truth you’re looking for—the foundation for your anger, the source of your demand for justice, the only thing that can end the outrage paradox—is not a feeling. It’s not a perspective.
It’s a Person.
You can stop listening to the echo and start listening to the Source.
The Subjective Jail.
Maybe you feel like you’ve found the solution.
Maybe you think: Fine, I’ll stop worrying about the whole world. I’ll just focus on my truth. I’ll look inward.
This is the great promise of the subjective world: liberation. No one can tell you what to do. Your feelings are the compass. Your perspective is the only reality that matters.
Sounds freeing, right? It’s not.
Absolute subjectivity is not a path to freedom; it’s a tiny, airless cell. It’s a subjective jail.
Think about it logically. If all truth is only true for you, then you have instantly disqualified every single major truth claim you rely on every day.
You can’t trust your memory. Was that conversation toxic, or does your mood make you believe it was toxic? If your feelings are the final authority, how do you judge a past event when your feelings about it change? You become a prisoner of your current emotional state.
You can’t trust your relationships. If your spouse says, “I love you,” that is objectively meaningless. It’s just their subjective experience at that moment. You can’t build a life on a truth that might change before breakfast. You’re left constantly questioning.
You can’t trust your mind. The core of absolute subjectivity is an old idea called solipsism—the belief that only your mind is sure to exist. When you reject all objective reality, you are forced back into the one thing you can’t deny: you exist. The rest of the universe becomes a giant projection, a film reel playing just for you.
And here is where the isolation hits. You are the only one who matters. You are utterly alone. The world you see has no shared reality, no shared ground, and no shared moral compass. The outrage is paralyzing, and the isolation is absolute.
You start to realize that the fight over whether the train murderer was failed by the system is minor compared to the fear that you are trapped in a reality only you can access. The search for truth becomes a desperate scramble to escape your own head.
But we were not designed to be isolated, judgmental monarchs of our own tiny worlds. We are designed for shared reality. We crave community, cooperation, and love. None of that works without a fixed, shared truth that exists outside of your personal opinion.
The Foundation of Freedom.
This is why the anger you feel—the echo of the law written on your heart—is your escape key.
The law written on your heart (Romans 2:15) is not a prison sentence. It’s a compass. It is the objective fact that points toward a solution that is bigger than your feelings and truer than your memory.
When you look for the source of that objective law, you are led out of the Subjective Jail. You find the universal standard that:
• Validates your anger at injustice (it was objectively wrong).
• Provides a consistent standard for empathy (God is the only True and Righteous Judge of motive and action, right and wrong).
• Guarantees shared reality (Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever).
The Gospel is not the end of truth; it is the fix for the broken subjective compass. It is the one objective truth that sets you free.
Question: Are you still okay being the sole judge of a world you can’t trust? Or are you ready to see the fixed, objective line that explains your outrage and frees you from yourself?
Your outrage is telling you something.
Not about your feelings.
But about reality.
Justice is real.
Which means truth is real.
Which means the Lawgiver is real.
The question is not whether you feel outrage — you do.
The question is whether you will follow it back to the One who wrote the law on your heart.
Further Reading & Resources 📚
I. Academic & Secular Sources
For those interested in the psychological and sociological analysis of moral disagreement in the digital age, I recommend exploring the research that validates the “Outrage Paradox”:
• Political Polarization and Moral Outrage on Social Media
o Authors: Jordan Carpenter, William Brady, Molly Crockett, René Weber & Walter Sinnott-Armstrong
o Source: Connecticut Law Review, Vol. 52, No. 3, Article (2021)
o Focus: This article proposes a theoretical model explaining how “moral outrage” (anger and disgust at a perceived moral violation) on social media leads to affective polarization, dehumanization, and a decay of civil discourse—the very chaos we see in daily news feeds.
II. ESV Scripture Anchors.
To explore the concept of an objective moral law written on the human heart, and the historical solution found in Christ:
Topic Scripture Reference (ESV) Purpose in Post
The Law on the Heart Romans 2:15 Explains the Outrage Paradox—why humans instinctively know right from wrong, even if they reject God’s law.
Objective Reality/Christ Hebrews 13:8 Guarantees shared reality and objective permanence: “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever.”
The Resurrection 1 Corinthians 15:17 Establishes the entire Christian faith on a single, objective, historical fact: “And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile, and you are still in your sins.”
